Trying to Improve Mammograms
Hester Hill Schnipper, LICSW, OSW-C Program Manager, Oncology Social Work
APRIL 20, 2017
Anyone who has ever had a mammogram has wondered why the experience has to be so uncomfortable. Many women experience it as discomfort, but some describe intense pain. We all know the jokes that begin: "If it were men...."
There have been advances in the technology of mammograms (think digital mammograms) that make the films more accurate, but the process hasn't changed. This brief article from Harvard Women's Health Watch explains the reasons, but isn't so hopeful about improvement.
Why isn't there a more comfortable mammogram procedure?
Ask the doctor
Published: April, 2017
Q. I have been smashed, squashed, pulled, and tugged annually for 25 years. Why isn't there a better way to take a mammogram?
A. We hear you! Compression mammography has been the "gold standard" for decades for one reason — it works. Flattening the breast makes ductal tissue easier to distinguish and reduces the amount of radiation required to do so. Studies have demonstrated that it is the most effective approach to breast cancer screening.
However, radiologists are still working to improve the experience for women. In 2014, a team from the Netherlands reported the results of a study of 433 women undergoing screening mammography using both the conventional compression technique and compression based on the individual woman's breast size and stiffness. The women reported significantly less discomfort following the image using personalized compression. Follow-up studies have demonstrated that the new technique provides images that are as good as those taken with conventional compression. This approach probably won't be coming to a mammography suite near you anytime soon, but it's a start.
Meanwhile, don't give up on conventional mammography. Let your technicians know about your past discomfort the next time you have a mammogram. There is much they can do to make the exam easier for you.
— by Hope Ricciotti, M.D., and Hye-Chun Hur, M.D., M.P.H.
Editors in Chief, Harvard Women's Health Watch