Used for Today?
An alcohol extract made from
has become popular in Germany as a treatment for various respiratory problems, including
pharyngitis (sore throat)
, and tonsillitis.
Fairly large studies have been performed to substantiate some of these uses.
For example, in one
, placebo-controlled study, 468 adults with recent onset of acute bronchitis were given either placebo or a standard alcohol extract of
3 times daily for a week.
The results showed a significantly greater improvement in symptoms in the treatment group as compared to the placebo group. On average, participants who received the real treatment were able to return to work 2 days earlier than those given placebo. Benefits were also seen in 2 other double-blind, placebo-controlled studies enrolling a total of almost 350 people with acute bronchitis.
When researchers pooled the results of four well-designed, placebo-controlled trials, they found that a standardized extract of
performed significantly better than placebo at reducing the symptoms of bronchitis by the seventh day of treatment.
Given this evidence,
appears to be effective for acute bronchitis.
Another double-blind, placebo-controlled study enrolled 143 children aged 6-10 years with a nondangerous form of
(technically, non-group A beta hemolytic strep tonsillopharyngitis).
On average, the total duration of the illness was reduced by 2 days in the treatment group as compared to the placebo group.
: Only a medical test can distinguish between the relatively nondangerous form of strep throat studied in this trial (non-group A strep) and strep throat of the potentially very dangerous A form (group A strep). For this reason, physician supervision is essential. See the
article for more information.
Finally, a double-blind study of 133 adults who had just come down with the
found that use of a standardized pelargonium extract at a dose of 30 ml three times daily significantly reduced the severity and duration of symptoms as compared to placebo.
It is not known how
might work, but its action is hypothesized to involve both direct antibacterial effects and immune function modification.
A typical adult dose of the tested standardized root extract is 30 drops three times daily. For children 6-11, this dose is typically reduced to 20 drops three times daily. However, other products beside the tested formulation may vary in strength. Therefore, we recommend that you follow the label instructions.
In clinical trials enrolling a total of over 2,500 adults and children, use of the tested, standardized extract produced few side effects, other than the usual occasional allergic reactions or digestive upset.
However, comprehensive safety testing has not been completed. There is no reliable evidence regarding safety in children under the age of 6, pregnant or nursing women, or people with severe liver or kidney disease.