Principal Proposed Treatments for Acne
| Other Proposed Treatments for Acne
The blackheads and sometimes painful pimples that we know as acne occur most commonly during adolescence, but they may persist into later life as well. There is much we still don't understand about what causes acne. We do know that during adolescence and other times of hormonal imbalance, such as around menopause, glands in the skin increase their levels of oil secretions. A combination of naturally occurring yeast and bacteria then breaks down these secretions, causing the skin to become inflamed and the pimples to eventually rupture. In severe cases, acne can lead to permanent scars.
Conventional treatment, which usually is quite successful, consists primarily of oral or topical antibiotics, cleansing agents, and chemically modified versions of
: Do not rely on any of the natural treatments discussed in this article to treat severe acne in which scarring is a possibility.
Principal Proposed Treatments for Acne
Studies suggest that people with acne have lower-than-normal levels of zinc in their bodies.
This fact alone does not indicate that taking zinc supplements will help acne.
studies have found zinc more effective than placebo but less effective than antibiotic therapy.
In one of these studies, 54 people were given either placebo or 135 mg of zinc as zinc sulfate daily. Zinc produced slight but measurable benefits.
Similar results have been seen in other studies using 90 to 135 mg of zinc daily,
although others failed to find that zinc helped.
Relatively weak evidence suggests that a lower and safer dose, 30 mg daily, may also be helpful.
A large double-blind trial (332 participants) compared 30 mg daily of zinc against a tetracycline-family medication often used for acne (minocycline at 100 mg daily).
The results showed minocycline is more effective than zinc.
taken at a dose of 250 mg daily,
appears to be no more effective than zinc, but when taken at 500 mg daily it seems to be considerably more effective.
Keep in mind that the dosages of zinc used in most of these studies are much higher than daily requirements, and have the potential for causing toxicity. Indeed, case reports indicate that people have made themselves extremely ill by taking zinc in hopes of treating their acne symptoms.
For more information, see the full
Tea tree oil has antiseptic properties and has been suggested as an alternative to benzoyl peroxide for direct application to the skin.
The best evidence for benefits with tea tree oil comes from a randomized, double-blind clinical trial of 60 people with mild to moderate acne.
In this study, participants were divided into two groups and treated with placebo or 5% tea tree oil gel. Over the 45-day study period, researchers evaluated acne severity in two ways: by means of counting the total number of acne lesions (TLC) and also by rating acne severity on a standardized index (ASI). The results showed that tea tree oil gel was significantly more effective than placebo at reducing both the number of acne lesions and their severity.
For more information, including dosage and safety issues, see the full
In a double-blind trial, 76 individuals with moderately severe acne were treated with either 4%
gel or 1% clindamycin gel (a standard antibiotic treatment).
Niacinamide proved to be just as effective as the antibiotic over an 8-week trial period. However, because this study lacked a
, its results are unreliable.
Other Proposed Treatments for Acne
medicine has shown some promise for acne. One study evaluated the potential benefits of an herbal combination containing the following constituents:
In this 4-week, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of 53 people with acne, combined topical and oral use of the herbal preparation significantly improved acne symptoms. Oral treatment alone was not effective.
Another controlled trial compared an extract of the Ayurvedic herb
against tetracycline for the treatment of acne, and found them equally effective.
Unfortunately, the study report does not state whether this trial was double-blind, and for this reason the results are not reliable. (For information on why double-blinding matters, see
Why Does This Database Rely on Double-blind Studies?
Other commonly mentioned natural treatments for acne include
. There haven't been any well-designed studies examining these treatments, however.
The effect of diet on acne is unclear. One interesting, though far from definitive, study compared a
low glycemic load diet
against a high carbohydrate diet, and found that the low glycemic load diet reduced acne symptoms.
Herbs and Supplements to Use Only With Caution
Various herbs and supplements may interact adversely with drugs used to treat acne. For more information on this potential risk, see the individual drug article in the
section of this database.